Illustration of Recognizes the role of evaluation in oral communication in the ICLE's Rigor and Relevance Framework
Quadrant C

In cooperative groups, students review each other's speeches: ask questions, respond to feedback or explain speech point choices or techniques in a positive manner. Students modify speech based upon feedback and redeliver speech with changes. Students log suggestions in notebook and write journal reflection about advice given.

Quadrant D

In a business class students develop product proposals and present their proposals to fellow students in a mock "think tank" forum. Students must effectively and respectively respond to questions and defend their proposal.

Quadrant A

Students review processes for impromptu speeches (receiving topic, brainstorming thoughts, formulating thesis or main point, developing supporting points/ideas, etc.).

Quadrant B

Students are given settings outside of school to give impromptu speeches: meetings, general opinions/critiques, toasts, etc. Students deliver speeches and modify during delivery based upon audience response and from suggestions during classroom experience. Students receive feedback about speech and respond to it in a journal entry.